How fools recruit: 'I'll know them when I meet them'

No matter how far we think Australian businesses have come with respect to recruitment and employment practices, there are always plenty of reminders that old habits die hard. 

One of these old habits is the classic client response to a recruiter who requests a job description; ‘I don't need a job description, I'll know them when I meet them'

This would be laughable if it weren't so common to hear, even in 2014. Considering the amount of money at stake in hiring somebody (not just direct costs like wages and recruitment costs but indirect costs like training and job/colleague/client adjustment time), it seems foolish in the extreme to be so cavalier as to not think it worthwhile to have anything in writing about the job you wish to fill or employee you wish to hire. What person would attempt to build a house without first having a plan? 

If you want to find your way to a destination, does a detailed map help or hinder you? Given the popularity of Google Maps I think we all know the answer. Of course a person may find their way to a destination without a map, but in all likelihood the journey will take longer and cost more. 

An effective job description broadly contains five things: 

  1. clarity about why the role exists (ie the overall purpose of the job)
  2. what needs to be done (ie the task or responsibilities of the role)
  3. how it needs to be done (eg the lines of authority, the demarcation with, and relationship to, other roles, resources available, etc)
  4. the performance to be achieved (the accountabilities or success criteria of the role)
  5. the key selection criteria (ie the existing capabilities required of candidates to be seriously considered for the role) 

The benefit to both the recruiter and the hiring manager is, I would hope, obvious; there is now a clear benchmark that both parties are working with. 

When a job description does not exist, all you have is a person's interpretation of what was said in a conversation about the vacancy. Such interpretations are both subjective and, of course, likely to be remembered differently by each side as time moves on. 

However a job description is really just the first piece of the recruitment puzzle. It is also critical to have a recruitment brief. 

The recruitment brief is a document that details all the information required to efficiently plan for, and execute, the recruitment of the position detailed in the job description.

An recruitment brief should contain, at least, the following: 

  1. Remuneration and benefits 
  2. The candidate sourcing process
  3. Ideal or projected start date
  4. The interview and assessment process
  5. The background checking steps
  6. Verbal offer and written offer process
  7. Recruitment budget
  8. Recruitment timeline
  9. Overall ownership of the recruitment process 

As you can see, there are many other factors besides the job description that need to be identified, considered and a decision made about, before the actual candidate sourcing process should begin. 

Completing, and working from, an accurate recruitment brief maximises the likelihood that the recruitment process will deliver the desired candidate within the projected time-frame and budget. 

Given the number of things that can occur outside of your control during a recruitment process, it is reckless to be ignorant, lazy or ill-considered with all the factors that are within your control during a recruitment process. 

‘I know them when I meet them'? 


I certainly know a recruitment fool when I hear one.

Views: 146

Add a Comment

You need to be a member of HR Daily Community to add comments!

Join HR Daily Community

© 2019   Created by Jo Knox.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service